HOT TRUB
October 26, 2000
Edited by: Peter LaFrance (plfrog@aol.com)
Presented by: American Brewer
===================================
Greetings,
This is the first posting of a news-alert e-mail service provided by American
Brewer.
This news letter will post items of special interest to brewers, members of the
brewing and distilling community, and members of the media that covers the
beverage alcohol business.
These postings follow-up the press releases distributed by services and
discovers the story-behind-the story. Should you wish to contribute in any way
to this venture please contact Peter LaFrance at plfrog@aol.com
If you wish to be dropped from this list please respond to this posting to
plfrog@aol.com and include the word remove in the Subject: line.
===============================================
ITEM:
DIPLOMACY OVER A BEER OR TWO
by
Hank Stewart
Over a couple beers, two of the more renowned figures of American craft brewing
turned their swords into pens, which they then used to sign a significant check.
The public first learned of the accord immediately following the Awards
presentation at the 2000 Great American Beer Festival, when Jim Koch and Sebbie
Buhler announced their respective companies, Boston Beer Company and Rogue Ales
were pledging $25,000 to promote the second annual American Beer Month to
be held in July 2001. How this came to pass is a story of how two rivals met
each other half way, and decided to take things a step further and help their
industry as a whole.
According to Koch, he and Rogue president Jack Joyce met at the bar of a Holiday
Inn in Baltimore during the Brewers' Conference, hoping to head off a couple of
potential trademark infringement battles. At issue were slogans being used to
promote the respective brands that contained the words "inside" and
"revolution." Rogue holds the trademark for "It's what's inside that counts,"
and Sam Adams had been using "It's what's inside." Meanwhile, Sam Adams holds
the trademark for "Sam Adams' Revolution," and Rogue had been using "So you want
a revolution?."
Recognizing that a court battle could be costly for each of them, Koch and Joyce
reached a compromise. Sam Adams would continue to use "It's what's inside," and
Rogue would continue to use "So you want a revolution?," each without fear of
retribution from the other. At that point, Joyce suggested Koch make a gesture
of good faith by donating $25,000 to promote American Beer Month. Koch agreed.
"The donation was made in the spirit of cooperation, which hasn't always been
prevalent in this industry," said Koch, who seemed to acknowledge his role in
past conflicts.
Other brewers have also contributed to the fund, including Larry Bell and John
Hickenlooper, each of whom chipped in $1000.
(When I contacted Hank Stewart soon after receiving this piece of news he add
the following: )
The $25,000 is coming from Boston Beer alone. It was Joyce's idea, but Koch
wrote the check.
I know it seems a little strange, but it's as if Koch bought the use of "It's
what's inside" from Joyce for $25,000 (and the use of "revolution"), but rather
than take the money, Joyce suggested donating it to American Beer Month. Thing
is, I'm not sure it's that clean-cut, and BB and Rogue are referring to it as a
joint donation.
--30--